top of page

BEYOND THE BREED: Dog Training Motivation Matters — What Makes Your Dog Want to Listen?

Writer: The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
5 days ago
11 min read
Samoyed vs. Shiba Inu. One works for treats. The other would rather you admire how handsome he is.
Samoyed vs. Shiba Inu. One works for treats. The other would rather you admire how handsome he is.

Dog Training Motivation Matters — What Makes Your Dog Want to Listen?

One of my dogs would probably sell his soul to the devil for a treat. The other would rather you put the treats away and spend a few minutes admiring how handsome he is.


And the funniest part? The first is a Shiba Inu. The second is a Samoyed.


If that doesn't make you question everything you've ever read about breed temperament, I don't know what will!


Meet Charlie and Baton, two of our young boys at Last Samurai Kennel who have been giving me a rather entertaining education in canine motivation. Both are adolescents, both have experience in the show ring, and both are perfectly capable of learning and working with people. But getting them excited about the same things? That's where life gets interesting.


Charlie believes food is one of life's greatest achievements. Baton believes he is one of life's greatest achievements. And somehow, I have to convince both of them that we're supposed to be working.


Welcome to my world.


Charlie: Will Work for Food. Will Also Forget His Manners for Food.


Let me introduce Charlie, our young Shiba Inu, whose relationship with food deserves its own chapter in the history of canine enthusiasm. Charlie loves toys, especially a good little squeaky one, but toys are merely an appetizer. Food is serious business. I'm fairly certain Charlie would sell his soul to the devil for a sufficiently delicious treat, then negotiate a second treat as a signing bonus.


You might think having a dog with such fantastic food motivation would make training an absolute breeze. And sometimes it does. Until we enter the show ring.


You see, Charlie has grown up associating dog shows with fun, excitement, attention and rewards, which is exactly what I want. I love seeing a young dog who enjoys being in the ring rather than treating the whole experience like an unpleasant obligation. There's just one small problem. Sometimes Charlie enjoys it a little too much.


Instead of standing beautifully stacked, showing off his structure and looking handsome for the judge, Charlie decides it's the perfect opportunity to launch himself toward the treat. Forget the elegant show dog. We now have a Shiba Inu auditioning for the national high-jump championships.


The funniest part is that Charlie genuinely wants to participate. He's excited, engaged and eager. He's simply having a little trouble remembering that the treats are supposed to reward the performance, not the aerial acrobatics.


Of course, Charlie is also going through adolescence. That delightful stage when a puppy begins developing the confidence of a mature dog, the impulse control of a caffeinated squirrel and a sudden fascination with testing every boundary you thought you'd already established.


So we're working on finding the right balance. I don't want to take away his enthusiasm, because that wonderful spark is part of what makes Charlie such an enjoyable young dog. I just need to help him channel it. We're practising calmer engagement, rewarding him for keeping his feet on the ground and building the patience to stand beautifully without attempting to climb into the bait pouch.


Some days we make wonderful progress. Other days, Charlie apparently believes gravity is optional. But that's the reality of training young dogs. Progress isn't always a straight line, especially when adolescence, excitement and a very powerful interest in snacks are all involved.


Charlie doesn't need convincing that working with me is worthwhile. He needs help learning that keeping all four paws on the ground is part of the job description.


And that brings me to a very different young fellow.


Baton: The Samoyed Who Didn't Read the Job Description


Baton is our 15-month-old Samoyed boy, and he's already earned his Champion title. Handsome? Absolutely. Mellow? Almost unbelievably so. Enthusiastic about doing absolutely everything I ask? Well, let's discuss that.


Baton is probably one of the mellowest young Samoyeds I've ever known. Sometimes I genuinely wonder whether somebody accidentally installed Shiba software in our Samoyed.


He doesn't rush into every situation. First, he observes, then he thinks, and then he considers his options. Eventually, if he feels the proposal deserves his attention, we might have a deal.


Offer him a treat and he may take it, politely decline or spend a moment considering whether the offer is likely to improve. Charlie would be absolutely horrified by this waste of perfectly good food.


But give Baton your undivided attention, and now we're talking!


Baton loves that one-on-one connection. Having your complete focus, hearing your praise and knowing that you're paying attention to him can be far more rewarding than anything in your treat pouch. Ask him to stand beautifully while you admire him, and he's perfectly content. The boy knows he's handsome. Apparently, the rest of us are simply there to acknowledge it.


And while he has already earned his championship, being 15 months old doesn't mean his teenage adventures are over. His version of adolescent rebellion just looks a little different from Charlie's. While Charlie is trying to launch himself into orbit for a snack, Baton is quietly deciding whether the proposed activity is worth interrupting his peaceful afternoon.


But here's something interesting I've noticed as he's matured: his motivation is changing.

At around 12 months, toys weren't nearly as exciting to him as they are now. We've worked on encouraging his interest in food, without much success. His toy drive, however, has developed noticeably over the past few months. Now, at 15 months, he's discovering that playing can be genuinely exciting, and I couldn't be happier about it.


We're exploring new ways to use that growing interest in toys to bring a little more playful energy into his training. Not because there's anything wrong with Baton's wonderfully mellow personality. Quite the opposite. I adore that about him. I simply want him to discover that working together can be fun in more ways than one.


We're not trying to turn our laid-back boy into a bouncing ball of energy. We're helping him find activities he enjoys and giving that playful side more opportunities to shine. And isn't that what good training should be?


Charlie needs help bringing his excitement down a notch, while Baton needs encouragement to bring his playful enthusiasm out. One is ready to sell his soul for a treat, and the other would rather receive a standing ovation.


Two very different dogs, teaching me exactly the same lesson: motivation isn't about finding the reward that every dog should want. It's about discovering what makes your particular dog light up.


Apparently, We're Paying in Different Currencies

Shiba Inu vs Samoyed training
Shiba Inu vs Samoyed training

Imagine showing up for work tomorrow. Your boss announces that you'll be completing several tasks, concentrating carefully and following instructions. You ask what you'll receive in return, and your boss replies, "Well, you should just be happy to do it."


I'm guessing you'd have a few questions.


Dogs may not understand employment contracts, but they certainly learn which activities lead to something worthwhile. And what's worthwhile to one dog might be completely uninteresting to another.


Charlie considers food a perfectly reasonable reason to put considerable effort into something. Baton finds your undivided attention much more valuable. Another dog might happily work for a ball, a game of tug or the chance to run. Some love praise and interaction, while others would trade an entire training session for permission to investigate a fascinating smell along the walking trail.


And then there are dogs who want cheese. Specifically cheese. The biscuit you've brought is apparently an insult to the negotiations.


Here's where we humans sometimes get things wrong. We assume that because we consider something a reward, our dog should feel the same way. Food is wonderfully useful in training, but it isn't our only option.


Think about a dog who loves sniffing. We can practise a little polite walking, then reward the effort with permission to explore that interesting patch of grass. Or consider a dog who adores fetch. A short training exercise followed by a game with its favourite ball may be far more exciting than another biscuit.


Baton reminds me that the value of a reward can change as dogs mature. A toy that barely interested him a few months ago is now becoming a wonderful opportunity for us to play together. The important thing is to keep observing rather than assuming we've already figured everything out.


Of course, this is usually when someone asks, "But isn't rewarding a dog just bribery? Shouldn't it listen because I said so?"


I always find that question interesting. We expect children to need encouragement while learning something new, yet sometimes expect dogs to understand and reliably follow instructions simply because we've issued them.


When we're teaching a new behaviour, we might use food or another reward to help the dog understand what we're asking. As it learns, we can begin asking for the behaviour before delivering the reward, rather than needing to display a treat first. That's teaching, not paying off a tiny furry criminal.


Although if your Shiba has convinced you to produce three varieties of cheese before agreeing to sit, you might want to review who's negotiating with whom.


The Puppy Training Department Opens Earlier Than You Think


One of my favourite things about raising puppies is watching them discover the world long before anyone expects them to understand a formal command.


By the time our puppies begin exploring beyond their whelping box, they're already learning from everything around them. Different surfaces, new toys, unfamiliar sounds, objects that move when pushed and, naturally, things that weren't intended to become toys but have received enthusiastic approval from the puppy inspection department.


Introduce something new into a puppy play area, and you'll often see several different approaches. One puppy may charge straight over, investigate enthusiastically and accidentally knock the entire thing sideways. Mission accomplished, whatever the mission was!


Another puppy may stand a little distance away, observe its littermates making questionable decisions and approach once it has gathered enough information. Very sensible. And somewhere in the middle, there's usually a puppy who completely ignores the carefully selected enrichment toy and discovers that the cardboard box it arrived in is far more interesting. Money well spent.


But there's a useful lesson hidden in all this entertainment. Puppies don't all approach challenges the same way, and they don't necessarily find the same things rewarding.


By providing safe opportunities to explore, investigate and solve manageable problems, we can encourage curiosity while learning more about each puppy's interests. Of course, there's a difference between letting a puppy work through a small challenge and leaving it frightened or overwhelmed. We want learning to be enjoyable, not an obstacle course designed by someone auditioning for a survival television show.


These early experiences don't determine a puppy's entire adult personality, but they give us valuable clues about how that puppy approaches the world. And sometimes the best way to encourage learning isn't to immediately show the puppy the answer. It's to give it a safe opportunity to discover something for itself.


Your Dog Heard You. The World Was Just Louder.


Here's something almost every dog owner has experienced.


Your dog comes beautifully when called inside the house. You practise in the yard and things are still going pretty well. Then you visit somewhere new, where there are people walking, birds moving, dogs playing and approximately eight thousand fascinating smells.


You call your dog. Nothing. You call again, and your dog glances at you before returning to investigate a particularly interesting blade of grass.


Did it forget its name? Has it decided to move out and begin an independent career? Probably not.


A familiar exercise in a quiet room isn't the same challenge as performing it somewhere busy and exciting. Dogs need opportunities to practise skills in different places, with distractions introduced gradually.


If your dog struggles, make the task easier. Move somewhere quieter, reduce the distance and use something your dog genuinely values as a reward. For recall, particularly with dogs who have strong chasing instincts, that also means sensible safety measures such as a leash or long line while training develops. Because even a very motivated dog can make an unfortunate decision when a rabbit suddenly joins the conversation.


And sometimes the distraction isn't the environment at all. Sometimes it's the reward itself.

Just ask Charlie.


His excitement about food can become so intense that concentrating on the actual exercise gets a little difficult. That's when more excitement isn't necessarily helpful. We may need to simplify the exercise, reward smaller moments of self-control and allow him to settle before asking for more.


There's another mistake we're rather good at making: continuing a training session long after the dog has given us its best effort.


Things are going wonderfully, so we decide to practise just one more exercise. Then another. And perhaps one more, because we're having such a good time. Before long, the dog is distracted, we're frustrated and the whole afternoon has turned into an argument nobody intended to have.


Short, enjoyable training sessions are often much more productive than endlessly repeating something. I'd rather have a dog finish thinking, "That was fun! Let's do it again!" than wondering when the training department will finally close for business.


With Baton, especially, I want his growing enthusiasm for toys and play to remain enjoyable. Turning every activity into a long obligation would rather defeat the purpose. And Charlie? His idea of "Let's do it again!" may still involve an attempted vertical takeoff.

We're working on that.


Same Goal. Very Different Training Plans.


This is what I find so interesting about having Charlie and Baton at similar stages of life. Both are young dogs learning to work with their handlers. Both need concentration, patience and the ability to perform familiar behaviours in exciting environments, but they don't need identical training approaches.


With Charlie, we're helping him manage excitement and understand that calm, controlled behaviour earns the reward. With Baton, we're encouraging engagement through activities he finds enjoyable, especially his developing interest in toys.


One needs to learn that more excitement isn't always better, while the other is discovering that a little more excitement can be rather fun.


That's why I don't believe in treating training as a one-size-fits-all recipe. The behaviour we're hoping to achieve may be the same, but the path to getting there can look very different.


I don't want Charlie to lose his enthusiasm, and I certainly don't want Baton to lose his lovely mellow personality. I want both dogs to enjoy working with me while developing the skills they need.


There is one important exception to all this talk about motivation, though. Sometimes a dog isn't refusing a reward or losing interest because the activity is boring. Sometimes it's worried, overwhelmed, exhausted or uncomfortable.


A dog that suddenly becomes reluctant to sit, jump, walk or perform a familiar activity deserves a closer look, including veterinary attention when pain or illness might be involved. We shouldn't assume every hesitation is a negotiation over payment.


Listening to what our dogs are telling us is part of working with them, too.


Final Thoughts: One Wants Cheese. The Other Wants Applause.


When I look at Charlie and Baton, I can't help smiling at how different they are.


Charlie, our adolescent Shiba, would happily reorganize his entire schedule if there were sufficient treats involved. Baton, our young Samoyed champion, would much rather have your complete attention and a little admiration for being such a handsome fellow.


One is learning that excitement needs a little self-control. The other is discovering that toys and play can bring a whole new level of enjoyment to his day. And I'm learning right along with them.


Because even after years of living, raising and working with dogs, there is always another personality, another challenge and another surprise waiting around the corner.


We can read every breed description, study training methods and learn all about canine behaviour, but none of that replaces paying attention to the individual dog standing in front of us.


The secret isn't finding a dog who wants to obey every command. It's learning how to make cooperation something that dog genuinely enjoys.


Sometimes that means finding a better reward. Sometimes it means slowing things down. And sometimes it means convincing a teenage Shiba that standing still for three seconds is not an unreasonable demand.


As for life with Charlie and Baton? Apparently, I've hired an enthusiastic contract negotiator and a very handsome employee who prefers payment in compliments. One is requesting a larger snack allowance, the other would like his photograph placed on the wall, and somehow, I'm still the one doing all the work.


Welcome to dog ownership.



Comments


bottom of page