top of page

BEYOND THE BREED: One Size Doesn't Fit All. Understanding Breed Temperament

Writer: The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
Nov 14
9 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Samoyed vs Shiba Inu. One wants to join the party. The other would like to know who invited everyone.
Samoyed vs Shiba Inu. One wants to join the party. The other would like to know who invited everyone.

Tell a Samoyed you're going somewhere, and you've probably got an enthusiastic volunteer before you've even found your shoes.


Tell a Shiba Inu the same thing, and you may get a long, thoughtful stare. Apparently, your travel plans are still awaiting approval.


Welcome to life with two breeds that can look at the exact same situation and come up with completely different ideas about what should happen next.


At Last Samurai Kennel, I get a front-row seat to this little comedy every day. We live with both Samoyeds and Shiba Inus, and while they share our routines, our people and plenty of the same experiences, they certainly don't share a single opinion on how to behave.


Of course, not every Samoyed is a social butterfly, and not every Shiba is a tiny, four-legged sceptic. That's the fun part. Breed history can explain quite a bit, but the dog standing in front of you will always have a personality of its own.


Before the dog beds, there were jobs


Today our dogs have comfortable beds, carefully selected food and toys that somehow cost more than ours. Most don't need to work for their supper, unless you count sitting politely while someone opens a bag of treats.


Their ancestors had rather different schedules.


Over generations, people developed dogs for different kinds of work. Some needed to cooperate closely with humans. Others searched for game, followed movement or made decisions while working away from their people. Many needed a bit of both. Those jobs helped shape the traits that became common in different breeds.


The modern dog may have retired from the original family business, but the instincts didn't receive a retirement letter.


The Samoyed: head of the welcome committee


Samoyeds developed alongside Indigenous communities in northern Siberia, doing a mixture of jobs that included herding reindeer, hauling and hunting. They also lived in close contact with their people. They needed stamina, flexibility and a willingness to work together, with enough independent thinking to cope when life didn't go according to plan.


And if you've ever shared a home with a Samoyed, that desire to be involved can be spectacularly obvious.


You're gardening? Excellent. Your Sammy has arrived to supervise the excavation department. You dig one hole, they'll dig three. Teamwork!


You're folding laundry? Wonderful. Apparently the clean towels were missing a fresh layer of white fur.


You're talking to someone? Hang on. There is a fluffy individual who feels this conversation has been terribly unfairly organized without them.


But a Samoyed isn't simply a happy face waiting for instructions. These were capable working dogs, and independent decisions were part of the job too. Your most devoted companion can still discover a fascinating smell across the yard and suddenly become unavailable for questions.


In other words, loving your company and agreeing with everything you say are not quite the same thing.


The Shiba Inu: quality control has concerns


The Shiba Inu comes from a different working background. Developed in Japan as a small hunting dog, the breed needed agility, sharp awareness and the ability to search and pursue game in challenging terrain.


That can help explain the way many Shibas approach new situations. They tend to notice things. They may prefer to watch first, investigate second and decide whether your suggestion is worth considering somewhere around step three.


A visitor arrives. The Samoyed may be halfway through organizing the welcome ceremony. The Shiba may remain a little farther back, evaluating the guest list and wondering why nobody informed security.


A new toy appears. The Samoyed wants to share the excitement. The Shiba might give it one careful inspection, then look at you as though you've confused a squeaky duck with an actual achievement.


Naturally, I'm teasing. Shibas can be playful, affectionate and wonderful training partners. They can form very strong bonds with their families. They're simply not always interested in announcing those feelings to the whole neighbourhood.


A Samoyed might declare, ‘You're my favourite human!’ loud enough for the next town to hear. A Shiba might quietly sit beside you and pretend the whole thing was a coincidence.


The Samoyed Volunteer Department — no experience necessary


Here's an imaginary afternoon that will probably sound familiar to anyone who lives with an eager Samoyed.


You're carrying things around the yard, trying to set up an activity or finish a little job. To your Samoyed, this is obviously a team project. Nobody has mentioned the job description, but that has never stopped a good volunteer.


Back and forth the dog goes, inspecting every item you put down. At some point, something is proudly picked up and carried away. You needed the bucket moved? Wonderful. Your Samoyed has brought you a garden glove instead.


Close enough. Employee of the Month.


Meanwhile, picture a Shiba watching from a few steps away. The Samoyed has made six trips, checked the bucket twice and created three new tasks for the human. The Shiba hasn't moved.


You can practically hear the commentary: ‘And this is why I don't volunteer.’


The funny part is that neither dog has necessarily misunderstood what's happening. The Samoyed may find the interaction itself rewarding: following along, being included, earning a little praise. The Shiba may be more interested in figuring out whether there's anything worth doing at all.


And watch how quickly that changes if something interesting moves through the grass. Suddenly, quality control is very much on duty.


Different motivations, different approaches. Neither makes the dog smarter, better or more deserving of a biscuit.


Instinct didn't disappear with the memory-foam mattress


This is where modern life with dogs gets a little ridiculous.


We've invited animals with generations of working instincts into our homes, bought them lovely beds and then acted surprised when they still behave like working or hunting dogs.

A Shiba spots a squirrel, and the universe shrinks to one furry target. The human at the other end of the leash is waving a perfectly good treat that, for once, has absolutely no market value.


A Samoyed hears a suspicious noise outside and decides an announcement is necessary. Visitor? Delivery? A leaf behaving strangely? Nobody knows yet, but apparently everyone needs to be informed.


It's funny until those instincts run straight into our rules: don't chase wildlife, don't drag me down the path and please don't hold a neighbourhood meeting every time a car door closes.

Understanding where a behaviour comes from doesn't mean letting it happen. It means we can prepare for it. Secure fencing, sensible leash habits, appropriate outlets and patient training are far more useful than demanding that a dog forget what generations of selection helped produce.


Instinct explains why a behaviour may be tempting. It does not excuse poor manners — or replace training.


Friendly, confident and interested are three different things


There's another assumption I'd love to retire: that the dog who rushes up to everyone must have the best temperament.


Maybe that dog is comfortable and delighted to say hello. Or perhaps it's overexcited, overwhelmed or hasn't learned to slow down. We need more than an enthusiastic entrance to know.


Likewise, a dog who hangs back and observes isn't automatically shy, frightened or poorly socialized. Some dogs simply prefer a moment to take things in. Others really are worried and need help. The difference is in the whole picture: body language, ease of movement, ability to relax and how the dog responds as the situation unfolds.


Imagine walking into a room full of strangers. One person starts chatting immediately. Another finds a comfortable spot, looks around and decides who they'd like to meet. Neither is automatically the more confident adult.


Dogs deserve the same courtesy.


And while we're on the subject, a dog doesn't owe everyone a cuddle. Some adore physical affection; others would rather play a game, sit nearby or simply keep you company. Walking away from a pat is a perfectly reasonable way to say, ‘Not right now.’ Especially with children, learning to respect that message is important.


Affection isn't measured by how long a dog will tolerate being hugged.


The breed gives you clues, not a crystal ball


If breed history gave us a complete description of every dog, life as a breeder would be wonderfully simple. We'd hand each family a personality chart and send them on their way.

Unfortunately for anyone who enjoys neat little categories, dogs haven't agreed to that arrangement.


Two puppies from the same litter can share parents, routines and a home while growing into very different characters. One may charge into a new game. Another wants to watch a little longer. One may seek attention constantly. Another is happy simply to know you're nearby.

Genes matter, but littermates don't inherit identical combinations. Experiences matter too, and even when puppies share an environment, they don't experience every moment in the same way. Their personalities also keep developing as they mature.


That's why I like watching puppies over time rather than placing enormous weight on one afternoon's ‘temperament test.’ A single observation can be useful; it just can't tell us the whole story of an adult dog who hasn't grown up yet.


Besides, I'm fairly sure a few puppies would prefer not to have their entire future career decided on a day when they were feeling particularly sleepy.


Same goal, different route


So what does all this mean when we're actually trying to teach the dog something?

Picture two dogs learning to welcome visitors politely. The enthusiastic one may need to practise keeping four paws on the floor. The reserved one may need guests to stop reaching for its head and allow it to approach in its own time.


Same goal: a calm, comfortable dog and visitors who survive the occasion with their dignity intact. Different teaching plans.


Recall is another good example. One dog may come running because returning to its human is the best part of the game. Another may need a much stronger history of rewards before leaving an interesting scent feels worthwhile. Add a squirrel to the scene and we should probably stop pretending that one lesson in the backyard was enough.


This isn't a Samoyed-good, Shiba-difficult situation. Both breeds need training, and individual dogs from either breed may surprise us. The point is to find out what motivates this dog, in this situation, and build from there.


We can expect good manners from every dog without expecting every dog to learn them in exactly the same way.


Before you fall in love with the fluffy face


As a breeder, I see how easily people fall for a breed's appearance. And really, how can I blame them?


A Samoyed looks like a smiling snowdrift that learned to walk. A Shiba looks like a beautiful little fox with a highly competent legal department.


But the face is only the introduction.


Are you ready for a dog who may want to be involved in almost everything? Can you appreciate a companion who prefers to assess a situation before joining in? What will you do when that charming hunting instinct notices the neighbour's chipmunk? How will you teach your enthusiastic working dog that the doorbell is not a request for a concert?


Those questions are much more useful than asking which puppy looks cutest in a photograph. For puppy placement, I want to understand a family's daily life and expectations, and I want to share what I've actually seen in the puppies: how they play, explore, recover from surprises and respond to people.


I can't promise exactly what a puppy will be like at five years old. No responsible breeder can. What I can do is help families start with realistic expectations — and remember that they are welcoming an individual, not a breed description with legs.


Please don't blame the breed for everything


There is a fine line between understanding instincts and using a breed label as a universal excuse.


‘It's a Shiba. They never come when called.’ ‘It's a Samoyed. They're supposed to bark.’ ‘That's just the breed.’


Well, yes, some behaviours are more common in certain breeds. But the moment we use that as a reason to give up on teaching, managing or helping a dog, we've missed the whole point.


A Shiba with a strong interest in chasing still needs safe management and recall practice. A cheerful, noisy Samoyed still needs to learn when the announcement department is closed. A reserved dog still deserves careful social experiences, and an outgoing dog still needs boundaries.


We can respect the instincts without handing them the keys to the household.


Two breeds. Two opinions. One very good lesson.


After years with Samoyeds and Shiba Inus, I've learned that there are plenty of perfectly good ways to be a dog.


One wants to join the fun before anybody explains what the fun is. Another would appreciate a few details, possibly in writing, before committing.


One may greet the world like an old friend. Another prefers to have a look around first. And just when you think you've got their personalities neatly figured out, the Samoyed decides to be the thoughtful observer and the Shiba becomes the life of the party.


Their history helps explain some of those habits. Their temperament, development and experiences shape the rest. The trick is to stop comparing every dog to a description on the internet and pay attention to the individual sharing our home.


Because understanding the breed is a lovely place to start. Understanding your own dog is where the real relationship begins.


And if you happen to live with both breeds? Congratulations. You've got a very enthusiastic activities committee and an exceptionally selective quality-control department.


Good luck getting them to agree on the agenda.


Comments


bottom of page