top of page

WHO STOLE THE SOUTH POLE?

Writer: The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
11 minutes ago
8 min read

The Curious Case of Etah, Antarctic Buck, and a Samoyed Legend That Refuses to Die

The Samoyed Through the Decades | A Last Samurai Kennel historical story


In December 1911, Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen made history when he became the first person to reach the South Pole.


But according to a story familiar to generations of Samoyed enthusiasts, Amundsen wasn't actually the first to arrive.


That honour supposedly belonged to a magnificent white Samoyed named Etah.


Now, as someone who lives with Samoyeds, I can absolutely believe one would insist on being first. Mine consider getting through a doorway ahead of me a major sporting achievement. But being first to the South Pole? That is a rather bigger claim, and the more I followed it through old photographs, memoirs and pedigrees, the more interesting the story became.


Because this isn't really a story about catching someone in a mistake. It is about how easily a wonderful tale can become accepted history—and how the real dogs, once we look a little closer, turn out to be every bit as interesting.


A Princess, a photograph, and a very convenient family connection


Our trail begins, unexpectedly enough, with a princess. Rosalie de Mercy-Argenteau, known as the Princess de Montglyon, was an early and influential Samoyed enthusiast in America. Her kennel owned Moustan of Argenteau, recorded as the first Samoyed registered with the American Kennel Club in 1906. Moustan's son, Champion de Witte of Argenteau, became the first American Samoyed champion in 1907.


There is even a wonderfully romantic account of Moustan having come to the Princess through Grand Duke Nicholas, brother of the Russian Tsar. I wouldn't dare try to improve that plot. Royalty, Russia and a handsome white dog are quite enough material for a novel, and Moustan's genuine place in early breed history needs no embellishment.


Historic portrait of Moustan of Argenteau, one of the earliest registered American Samoyeds.
Moustan of Argenteau, historic portrait supplied from the Icecrown Samoyed history collection.

 

The mystery starts with another dog in the Princess's life: Etah. In her 1925 memoir, The Last of a Race, she included a photograph of him. Its caption linked Etah to Antarctic Buck as his son and to the lead of Amundsen's South Pole team. Yet the book offers no substantial account of Etah's alleged expedition career—no dates, no journey home, no explanation of how he came into her hands. For a dog credited with an astonishing polar achievement, he leaves a surprisingly small paper trail.

 

Historical photograph identified as Etah, the Samoyed associated with a disputed South Pole expedition legend.
Etah, as identified in historical Samoyed material.

The caption itself has an awkward little wrinkle: read one way, it makes Etah the expedition leader; read another, that distinction might refer to his supposed father, Antarctic Buck. Neither interpretation sits comfortably with what we know of Amundsen's actual dogs.


And once a beautiful picture and an irresistible claim have appeared together in print, they tend to travel. Other breed histories repeated the tale; with retelling came that extra flourish that Etah was the first living creature to reach the South Pole. It is the sort of detail people remember long after they forget where they read it. I certainly understand the temptation. Who wouldn't love to discover that a Samoyed had quietly beaten the explorers to their own destination?


Before handing Etah the trophy, though, we need to meet the dog who was supposed to be his father.


The dog who came from nowhere


Antarctic Buck sounds like the name of a dog born with an impressive résumé. His actual history begins more modestly: at a zoo in Sydney, Australia, without a known pedigree or a reliable account of how he got there.


Historic portrait of Antarctic Buck, an influential early Samoyed discovered at Sydney's Moore Park Zoo.
Antarctic Buck, in an early photograph reproduced in historical Samoyed material.

Ernest Kilburn-Scott—one of the people who, with his wife Clara, helped establish the Samoyed in Britain—encountered Buck at the Moore Park Zoo. For years the dog's beginnings were connected with Carsten Borchgrevink's Southern Cross Antarctic expedition of 1898–1900. Depending on the version, Buck was a veteran of that expedition, a descendant of its dogs, or simply an animal whose mysterious appearance invited an adventurous explanation.


There is a rather important witness who complicates that neat story: Ivy Kilburn-Morris, Ernest and Clara's daughter, who grew up among the family dogs and later recorded her memories of those early years. Ivy recalled that her father found Buck at the zoo in 1906, after the dog had apparently been there for six years. Her point was straightforward: he came with no known history. Ernest took him back to England in 1908. After quarantine and a show appearance, Buck died of distemper; Ivy remembered that only five of his puppies survived the outbreak.


That account doesn't tell us where Buck was born. It tells us something almost as useful: where the evidence stops.


I have spent enough years looking at pedigrees to know how badly we sometimes want a blank space to contain something exciting. Maybe Buck really did descend from expedition dogs. It is possible. But a possibility and a documented pedigree are two different things, however splendid the name Antarctic Buck looks on a page.


What interests me more is that this unknown zoo dog crossed an ocean, entered a young breeding population, and left offspring whose names can still be traced. He didn't need a personal South Pole medal to matter.


What Antarctic Buck actually left behind


Here is where the story becomes especially appealing to the breeder in me. Buck's own beginnings may be elusive, but his contribution didn't disappear with him.


Early pedigrees record Southern Cross and South Pole, both born in 1909 and listed as sons of Antarctic Buck and Kviklene. Southern Cross appears as the sire of Champion Antarctic Bru, while South Pole became the sire of Champion Zahra. Follow the branches farther and Buck's ancestry appears through more than one route behind Champion Kara Sea, born in 1924 and remembered among the most successful early show Samoyeds.

So the dog whose past was a mystery became part of a future that breeders could actually record. I find that far more moving than a borrowed expedition legend. A pedigree is not a fairy tale, although some of the old ones certainly invite detective work.



Ivy Kilburn-Morris pictured with dogs from the early Farningham Samoyed kennel in England.
Miss Ivy Kilburn-Scott (later Kilburn-Morris) with the Farningham Samoyeds. Archival image; historical attribution: Sport and General Press Agency.

 

The photograph of Ivy with the Farningham dogs is one of my favourites for that reason. Those aren't merely fluffy faces from a distant century. They represent people making decisions about type, working ability and the generations they hoped would follow. Ivy was not some passing name in a footnote: she was Ernest and Clara's daughter, part of the kennel's life, and a voice worth hearing when we discuss what her family actually knew about Buck.


And that brings us back to the question that started this whole adventure. If Etah and Buck don't belong on Amundsen's South Pole team, who does?


Meanwhile, at the South Pole...


The dogs pulling Amundsen's sledges on the historic journey were Greenland dogs. His own expedition records are unusually detailed about obtaining and working with them. The team reached the South Pole on 14 December 1911, with five men and dogs whose labour was central to the achievement.


There is another delightful complication to the familiar picture of a single heroic 'lead dog': the teams were often harnessed in a fan arrangement rather than in the straight line we might imagine. Giving one Samoyed the starring role makes for a terrific story, but it doesn't fit the surviving expedition accounts.


One dog we can follow is Obersten, meaning the Colonel. He was a Greenland dog on Oscar Wisting's team, and his story carries us beyond the famous photograph of a flag planted at the Pole.


Obersten, the Greenland sled dog who reached the South Pole with Roald Amundsen's expedition in 1911.
Obersten ('The Colonel'), the Greenland dog who travelled to the South Pole with Oscar Wisting's team. Historical photograph via the Amundsen Museum (MiA).

Obersten was one of three Greenland dogs brought back to Norway after the expedition—along with Lucie and Storm—and, according to the Amundsen Museum, the only one of those three who had travelled all the way to the Pole. After living for a time at Amundsen's home, he went to live with Wisting in Horten in 1914.

 

Historical photograph of Obersten, a Greenland dog from Amundsen's South Pole expedition, alongside a person.
Obersten in an archival photograph supplied from the Amundsen Museum collection (MiA).

And this is the part of the research that stayed with me. Obersten became a familiar local character. He apparently liked visiting the butcher, which sounds like a sensible retirement plan to me, and Wisting later remembered the dog sitting outside Salvation Army meetings, listening to the singing and music in all kinds of weather. After Obersten died, probably around 1919 or 1920, Wisting wrote of missing him as one would miss someone dearly loved.


Not bad for a dog who gets considerably less attention in Samoyed legend than one who may never have set paw on Antarctic ice.


Obersten's preserved remains are displayed at the Ski Museum in Holmenkollen alongside equipment from Amundsen's expedition. There is something bittersweet about seeing him there: not a breed legend, not a pretty white silhouette borrowed for an article, but one particular dog whose long working journey and later life are recorded.

 

Preserved remains of Obersten, the Greenland dog from Amundsen's South Pole expedition, displayed at the Ski Museum in Norway.
Obersten on display at the Ski Museum, Holmenkollen, with South Pole expedition equipment. Photo: Skimuseet i Holmenkollen, via the Amundsen Museum.

And yes, Amundsen did later work with dogs described as Samoyeds on his Maud Arctic expedition. That is part of our breed's broader polar history, and worth celebrating in its own right. But the Maud expedition was not the 1911 dash to the South Pole. Two different voyages are not one interchangeable story, however much easier that would make the caption writing.


So who really stole the South Pole?


I don't think anyone deliberately stole anything. Historical information passes from a memoir to a breed book, from a club article to a website, and somewhere along the way a tentative statement starts sounding like a settled fact. Even well-respected sources, including the American Kennel Club's published historical overview, reflect versions of the older account. I don't see that as a reason to point fingers. It is a reminder that we are all working with records left by people who didn't know someone would still be arguing about their dogs more than a century later.


For me, the lesson isn't that Samoyeds deserve less credit. Quite the opposite. Their real history in northern communities, on expeditions, in harness and in early breeding programs is fascinating without asking them to collect every polar achievement in sight. Antarctic Buck's contribution matters whether or not we ever learn where he was born. Etah's photograph is still a lovely piece of breed history, even if the story attached to it cannot be supported. And Obersten deserves to have his own name remembered.


I'm not claiming to have every answer. I'd be delighted if an overlooked letter, a kennel record or a properly identified photograph added another piece to the puzzle. That's half the fun of digging through archives: sometimes the dogs surprise us long after they're gone.

So here's one for the comments. When a much-loved breed story clashes with historical evidence, should we keep telling it as legend, or is it time to rewrite the caption?

And if anyone has found the missing documents that could settle Etah's family tree, please share them. The Samoyed community loves a good mystery. We also love being right—but I suspect that particular trait isn't exclusive to our dogs.


Historical sources and photograph notes


1. Jim Osborn, “The Legend of Etah,” Samoyed.org: https://www.samoyed.org/legend-etah/

2. Helen Gabb, “The Myths and the Mystique Surrounding Early Samoyeds and Their Owners,” reproduced by Icecrown Samoyeds: https://www.icecrownsamoyeds.com/samoyed-history/

3. Amundsen Museum (MiA), “1912–14, the South Pole dog Obersten, photographs”: https://amundsen.mia.no/en/resource/1912-14-the-south-pole-dog-obersten-photographs/

4. Amundsen Museum (MiA), “Amundsen's dogs”: https://amundsen.mia.no/en/resource/amundsens-dogs/

5. Amundsen Museum (MiA), “1910–1912 Fram expedition”: https://amundsen.mia.no/en/resource/1910-1912-fram-expedition/

6. Amundsen Museum (MiA), “1918–25 Maud expedition”: https://amundsen.mia.no/en/expeditions/maud-expedition/

7. American Kennel Club, “Samoyed History: From Nomadic Hunters to Fluffy Friends”: https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/dog-breeds/samoyed-history/

8. Pedigree Database, historical entries for Southern Cross, South Pole, Antarctic Bru and Kara Sea: https://www.pedigreedatabase.com/samoyed/


Comments


bottom of page