top of page

THE BLACK SAMOYED. TRUE OR FALSE?

Writer: The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
Nov 2
7 min read

A little journey through the history of the dogs behind our modern Samoyed


Every once in a while, something pops up in the Samoyed world that makes me stop scrolling and start digging. Recently, it was the question of black Samoyeds. Did they really exist? Were they part of the original Siberian dog population? Or is this simply another internet story that has taken on a life of its own?


I have always found breed history fascinating, particularly when it challenges the neat little boxes into which we sometimes place our modern dogs. So, rather than relying on social media discussions, photographs with questionable captions, or somebody's recollection of what their great-grandfather once owned, I decided to go back to the historical records.


And what I found was considerably more interesting than a simple yes or no.


Before we begin, one thing needs to be clear: this is not an argument for changing the Samoyed breed standard, introducing new colours, or promoting unusual coat variations. It is an exploration of history. Understanding the dogs that came before our modern Samoyed is part of understanding how the breed we know today came to be.


And the historical record deserves a closer look.


So, where do we start looking?

Well, we have to travel quite a long way back, and not just to the first Samoyeds appearing in European show rings.


Long before anyone worried about breed standards, championship titles or whether a dog had enough coat for the judge's liking, these dogs were living and working alongside the indigenous people of northern Siberia.


And life up there wasn't exactly a holiday.


Some dogs helped with hunting, others watched over reindeer, guarded settlements or pulled sledges. They were valued for what they could do, how well they could work and how reliably they lived alongside their people.


Naturally, these dogs weren't all identical. They lived across enormous territories, among different communities, and had different jobs to do.

This is where things start getting interesting.


Early historical accounts describe predominantly white dogs among some nomadic communities, but also smaller herding dogs in other communities that could be white, black and white, or brown and white. The historical book we consulted calls some of these smaller dogs the Renvall-Hund or Elkhound type.

So, when we start asking whether black dogs existed among the ancestors and related populations of the Samoyed, the answer is already becoming rather interesting.


But I wanted to go further than somebody's description in an old book. What did the explorers actually see?


The explorers bring back more than stories

One of the most interesting names in this story is Fridtjof Nansen. After his 1888 Greenland expedition, he became convinced that dogs were essential for serious Arctic travel. In 1894, while preparing for another expedition, he asked Russian explorer Baron Eduard von Toll to help him obtain good sled dogs from Siberia.


Alexander Trontheim was sent to purchase the dogs. The original plan involved buying Ostyak dogs, but von Toll preferred dogs from the Tungus branch of the Samoyed people, whose draught dogs were considered better suited to the work.


Trontheim eventually purchased 40 sled dogs near Berezov. Getting them to the coast was no small errand: the dogs travelled with a large reindeer herd, handlers and supplies, and the journey took three months.

Siberian sled team pictured with a polar bear.
Siberian sled team pictured with a polar bear.

When Nansen first met the dogs, he described many as long-haired and snow-white, with upright ears and gentle expressions. But he also mentioned shorter-coated, fox-like dogs, as well as black and spotted individuals.


That is the detail that made me stop and read the passage twice.


Nansen was describing the dogs he actually encountered, not trying to win an argument about modern coat colours. His account tells us that the Siberian dog populations he saw were not all identical.


It does not prove that every black or spotted dog he saw was a direct ancestor of today's registered Samoyed. It does, however, make it very difficult to claim that darker dogs were simply invented by modern internet discussions.


The first dogs in England were not all white

Now let's move forward to the dogs who helped establish the breed in England. The early imports came from several parts of the north, including western Siberia, the Ural Mountains and Novaya Zemlya.


One of the best-known early arrivals was Sabarka, brought to England by Ernest Kilburn-Scott after his 1889 journey to Archangel. The historical account describes Sabarka as a deep biscuit. He was valued for his good head, stand-off coat, curled tail and carriage.


Sabarka, the original import brought to England by Ernest Kilburn-Scott in 1889. Sabarka, the original import brought to England by Mr Kilburn Scott in 1889. His colour was described as ‘deep biscuit’’
Sabarka, the original import brought to England by Ernest Kilburn-Scott in 1889. Sabarka, the original import brought to England by Mr Kilburn Scott in 1889. His colour was described as ‘deep biscuit’’
Ernest Kilburn-Scott with Sabarka, photographed circa 1893.
Ernest Kilburn-Scott with Sabarka, photographed circa 1893.

The historical book also gives us a photograph of Peter the Great himself, owned by the Hon. Mrs. McLaren Morrison. This is especially useful: instead of relying only on a litter attributed to him, we can now show the dog identified by the original caption.


Peter the Great, owned by Mrs. McLaren Morrison. Photograph by J. H. Clarke
Peter the Great, owned by Mrs. McLaren Morrison. Photograph by J. H. Clarke

The same historical source also includes a photograph captioned simply “Pedro, owned by Mrs Cammack.” The image is striking, and it belongs in this discussion of early dogs whose appearance differs from the familiar white Samoyed. The original caption identifies the dog as Pedro; the photograph itself is monochrome, so it should not be used alone to make a definitive claim about his precise coat colour or pedigree.

 

Pedro, owned by Mrs Cammack.
Pedro, owned by Mrs Cammack.

The Kilburn-Scotts also acquired Whity Pechora, a cream-coloured bitch. These early dogs were part of a small and varied foundation population at a time when the modern breed was still taking shape.

 

Whity Pechora, the cream-coloured bitch acquired by the Kilburn-Scotts.
Whity Pechora, the cream-coloured bitch acquired by the Kilburn-Scotts.

It is easy to look at today's Samoyed and assume that the dogs at the very beginning must have looked exactly the same. But the early records tell a more complicated story. Breeders were working with a limited number of imports and gradually deciding which features they wanted to preserve.


The mating that helped make the English Samoyed white


A particularly important chapter begins in 1901. Lady Sitwell had imported a snow-white Russian dog named Musti. When Musti was bred to Whity Pechora, the resulting litter was described as white.


The historical account calls this mating the beginning of the all-white Samoyeds in England. The litter included Nansen, who became a successful show dog, and the influential bitch Olgalene.


That doesn't mean one mating magically changed every Samoyed in England. But it does show how a small number of influential dogs and deliberate breeding choices helped shape the appearance of the developing breed.


As the years passed, white dogs became increasingly influential. Breeders were also selecting for type, expression, coat, structure and temperament. The Samoyed was becoming a recognizable show breed, not simply a collection of imported northern working dogs.


From expedition companion to show-ring dog

The early twentieth century brought clubs, written standards and more organized breeding. The Samoyede Club was founded in England in 1909, and the Kennel Club gave Samoyeds a separate classification in 1912.


Some of the dogs from this period became important sires and show winners. The historical pages include photographs of Antarctic Buck, Houdin and Nansen, followed by later influential champions such as Kara Sea and Polar Light of Farningham.


The breed was becoming more consistent, and breeders were increasingly focused on preserving a recognizable Samoyed type. White became the dominant image of the breed, and the familiar modern picture took hold.


The story did not end with one colour, one breeder or one famous dog. It was the result of many people making choices over several generations. That is how breeds develop: a little at a time, through the dogs selected to produce the next generation.


So, was there ever a black Samoyed?

Here is where I think the answer needs a little care.

If we are talking about the wider indigenous dog populations associated with the Samoyed peoples, historical accounts describe black, black-and-white and brown-and-white dogs. Nansen also recorded black and spotted dogs among the Siberian dogs he encountered.

If we are talking about the early dogs imported into England, the records describe dogs that were not white, including the deep-biscuit Sabarka and cream-coloured Whity Pechora.

But if we are talking about the modern registered Samoyed, black is not an accepted coat colour under the Canadian Kennel Club breed standard. The recognized colours are pure white, white and biscuit, cream, and all biscuit.


Those are three related parts of the story, but they are not the same thing. The historical dogs of northern Siberia, the early imported foundation stock and the modern standardized breed should not be casually treated as one identical population.

And that, really, is the point.


A little history does not change the breed

I am not suggesting that we should change the Samoyed standard or start looking for unusual colours. I love the breed for what it is, and I believe responsible breeders have a duty to protect its defining characteristics.


But I also think we should be comfortable looking honestly at the past. The Samoyed did not arrive in Europe as a perfectly uniform white show dog. Its story began much earlier, among working dogs living with northern communities, and the breed we know today took shape through exploration, imports and generations of selective breeding.


So, the next time somebody asks whether black Samoyeds existed, I wouldn't dismiss the question quite so quickly.


The historical record does describe darker dogs among the wider populations associated with the Samoyed peoples. It also documents a gradual move towards the white dog that became the modern breed.


That doesn't mean a solid black dog is an acceptable modern Samoyed. It means the history is more interesting than a simple yes or no.


And honestly, isn't that why we started digging in the first place?


The history of a breed is worth preserving, too.


1 Comment


Rich J
Nov 04

Fascinating research, well done and thank you. I have always believed there were black Sam’s. Knowledge gleaned almost certainly from the same book as yourself. After your piece, I shall continue to believe especially as I think also in the article there is a statement saying all Sam’s have a single black hair. All seven of mine have had one. Coincidence? I think not.

You also asked about what we would keep from the Sam’s we have today. The easy answer is the RKC Breed Standard and I believe the Canadian one are spot on as long as Judges follow it and apply it. Every dog judged will have a fault - even Nikara Diamond Dancer - but the…

Like
bottom of page