top of page

BEYOND THE BREED: Your Dog Isn't Stubborn. You're Just Not Speaking Dog.

Writer: The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
The Last Samurai Journal | Ananastassia Kibzoun-Shtefan
Nov 12
12 min read

Understanding dog temperament, intelligence and communication through the eyes of two very different breeds.

 

Different dogs, different ways of exploring, playing and engaging with the world.
Different dogs, different ways of exploring, playing and engaging with the world.

The Dog Behind the Behaviour


Spend enough time around dogs and you'll eventually hear it: “He's stubborn.” “She's not listening.” “He's doing it on purpose.” “She's too independent.” And if you live with a Shiba Inu, you may have heard all four before breakfast.


But what if the dog isn't being difficult? What if we're simply expecting a dog to think, communicate and respond exactly the way we do?


Dogs don't experience the world as miniature humans in fur coats. They have their own instincts, motivations, social preferences and ways of processing information. Understanding those differences is where a better relationship begins.


At Last Samurai Kennel, sharing our home with both Samoyeds and Shiba Inus offers a daily reminder that there is no universal instruction manual for dogs. The two breeds have very different histories and working purposes, and those differences can be fascinating to observe. Neither approach is better. They are simply different.


1. The Dog Behind the Behaviour: Understanding Temperament


Temperament is the foundation of how a dog tends to respond to the world. It includes relatively stable behavioural tendencies influenced by genetics, but it is also shaped by development, learning and life experience.


Some dogs naturally approach new situations with enthusiasm. Others prefer to observe before participating. Some are socially outgoing, while others are more selective about their interactions. These differences are not automatically signs of good or bad temperament.


The Samoyed: The Social Participant


The Samoyed developed as a versatile working companion in Arctic communities. Its historical roles included herding, hunting, hauling and living closely alongside people. That background helps explain why many Samoyeds are socially engaged, expressive and interested in being part of whatever their humans are doing.


In a home or kennel environment, that can mean a dog who wants to investigate visitors, join household activities and participate in training simply because being involved is rewarding. Of course, a Samoyed can also be distracted, independent-minded or wonderfully creative when it comes to finding something more interesting than the exercise you planned.

 

 A Shiba taking a moment to observe: watching first can be part of an individual dog's approach.
A Shiba taking a moment to observe: watching first can be part of an individual dog's approach.


The Shiba Inu: The Independent Observer


The Shiba Inu has a different history. Developed as a hunting dog in Japan, it needed alertness, environmental awareness and the ability to work with a degree of independence. That background can still be seen in many modern Shibas.


A Shiba may pause to assess a situation before approaching. It may prefer to watch rather than immediately participate. It may understand a cue perfectly well and still take a moment to decide whether the proposed activity is worth its time. That last part can be particularly entertaining for the human on the other end of the leash.


But independence should not be confused with insecurity, poor socialization or an inability to form strong relationships with people. A confident Shiba can be affectionate, socially connected and deeply attached to its family without needing to greet every person or dog it encounters.

 

Curiosity and play are part of how young dogs explore their surroundings.
Curiosity and play are part of how young dogs explore their surroundings.

Two puppies, the same age, two different approaches


Right now, I have a particularly interesting opportunity to observe these differences firsthand. Two puppies, almost three months old, are growing up under our roof: Winnie, our Samoyed girl, and Mishu, our Shiba Inu boy.


They are close in age, but their approaches to the world are already quite different.


Winnie is very much my little shadow. She follows me around, checks in with me and seems to look for that little bit of reassurance or praise. She often watches me for a cue about what comes next. Her natural tendency is to stay connected, participate and find out what I would like her to do.


Winnie — a young Samoyed who often keeps close to her person 
Winnie — a young Samoyed who often keeps close to her person 

 

Winnie's people-focused approach is already a familiar part of daily life.
Winnie's people-focused approach is already a familiar part of daily life.

Mishu, on the other hand, takes a different approach. He observes first. He seems to want to take in what is happening before deciding whether he wants to participate. He doesn't rush forward, headfirst into every new interaction. More often, he hangs back, watches and processes the situation from a little distance.


Mishu — taking in the scene before deciding how to engage.
Mishu — taking in the scene before deciding how to engage.

 

And I find this fascinating. Both puppies are at the same stage of development, but they are already showing us different ways of gathering information and interacting with their environment. Winnie tends to look toward her person for guidance and engagement. Mishu appears more inclined to look at the situation itself before deciding how to respond.


It would be tempting to label Winnie as the eager one and Mishu as the independent one. But I would rather keep observing them than rush to define who they are at such a young age. These are early tendencies, not permanent personality descriptions. Puppies continue to develop, and their experiences will shape how these traits appear as they mature.


Same parents, same litter, two completely different personalities


And if anyone thinks these differences are simply a matter of breed, let me introduce two of our mature Samoyed girls: Zoe and Panda.


They are littermates. Same mother, same father, same birthday, and they grew up in the same environment. Yet, if you spent a day with them, you might wonder how two sisters could be so different.


Zoe is the ultimate lovey-dovey Sammy. She wants to be wherever her humans are. She loves interaction, enjoys pleasing people and is always ready to participate in whatever activity we come up with. If the children are around, she wants to be part of their world. If I have something for her to do, she is usually happy to oblige.

 

Zoe — affectionate, people-focused and happy to be part of the family's activities.
Zoe — affectionate, people-focused and happy to be part of the family's activities.

 

Zoe's social style is expressed through her eagerness to stay connected with her people.
Zoe's social style is expressed through her eagerness to stay connected with her people.

Panda is a different story. She is more independent and observant. She likes to assess what is happening around her and decide for herself when she wants to participate. She enjoys affection, but it needs to be on her terms.


If the children approach when she isn't interested in being touched, she will simply move away. Her message is quite clear: “Not right now, thank you.” That doesn't make her aggressive or unfriendly. It means she has her own social preferences and communicates her boundaries.

 

Panda — comfortable observing and choosing when to engage. 
Panda — comfortable observing and choosing when to engage. 
Panda's expression and posture offer a glimpse of her individual character.
Panda's expression and posture offer a glimpse of her individual character.
Panda prefers some activities on her own terms — including a good game of fetch.
Panda prefers some activities on her own terms — including a good game of fetch.

Panda would much rather bring you a ball and invite you to play fetch than throw herself onto her back, all four paws in the air, requesting an extended belly-rub session. Zoe, meanwhile, might consider both activities equally wonderful.


And I think this comparison is particularly important. We are talking about two Samoyeds, from the same litter, with the same genetic parents, raised with the same care and opportunities. Yet their social preferences, motivations and ways of interacting with people are noticeably different.


This is a reminder that breed characteristics describe tendencies, not identical personalities. Genetics matter, but they do not produce carbon copies. Individual temperament, development and personal preferences matter too.


It is also a reminder that affection should never be measured by how much physical contact a dog tolerates. A dog who chooses to move away is communicating, not misbehaving. Respecting that choice is part of building trust.


Sometimes the best thing we can teach children about dogs is that love does not mean insisting on a hug. It means understanding when the other side wants one.


Watching Winnie and Mishu alongside Zoe and Panda is a wonderful reminder that two puppies can be raised with similar care, or two littermates can share the same parents, and still approach the world in remarkably different ways. The goal is not to make every dog behave identically. It is to understand what we are working with.


2. Intelligence Isn't Measured in Sits and Stays


One of the biggest misunderstandings in dog ownership is the idea that obedience and intelligence are the same thing. They are not. A dog who responds immediately to a command is demonstrating a particular kind of learned behaviour. That does not necessarily mean it is more intelligent than the dog who pauses, investigates or finds another way to solve a problem.


Psychologist Stanley Coren popularized three broad categories of canine intelligence:

· Instinctive intelligence: abilities associated with the purpose a dog was bred to perform.

· Adaptive intelligence: the ability to learn from experience and solve problems.

· Working and obedience intelligence: the ability to learn and respond to cues taught by people.


These categories are a useful introduction, although canine cognition is more complex than any three-part classification.


Consider two famous examples of canine learning. Rico, a Border Collie, demonstrated the ability to recognize more than 200 toy names. Chaser, another Border Collie, learned the names of more than 1,000 objects. Remarkable abilities, certainly. But they do not mean that every dog should be evaluated by how many toys it can identify.


Imagine giving two dogs a puzzle: a treat is placed inside a container that is difficult to open. One dog might look toward its human for help. Another might continue experimenting with the container. A third might decide that the puzzle is not worth the effort and go looking for something else.


Those responses may reveal different strategies, social tendencies and motivations. They do not, by themselves, establish which dog is smarter.


In our experience with Samoyeds and Shibas, this distinction is particularly useful. A dog that is eager to work with a person may make training look effortless. A dog that prefers to investigate independently may require a different approach.


The important question is not simply, “How quickly does my dog obey?” It is also, “How does my dog learn, what motivates it, and what does it do with the information?”


3. Motivation Matters: Why Doesn't My Dog Listen?


Let's be honest: dogs do not always find our priorities particularly compelling. We may be focused on practising a perfect recall. Our dog may be focused on a bird, an interesting scent, another dog or an entirely different project.


A dog may understand a cue but struggle to respond because the environment is too distracting, its excitement level is too high, the reward is not meaningful enough, or the behaviour has not been practised in that particular setting. A command learned in the kitchen does not automatically become reliable in a busy park.


For a socially motivated dog, interaction, praise or a shared activity may be powerful rewards. Another dog may be more interested in food, movement, scent exploration or the opportunity to solve a challenge. And sometimes the reward we offer is simply not competitive with what the environment has to offer.


A useful training question is: What does this particular dog find rewarding?

Instead of repeating a cue louder and louder, consider changing the conditions. Reduce distractions, make the exercise easier, improve the reward and build reliability gradually. Training is not a contest of wills. It is a process of teaching a dog what a behaviour means and making it worthwhile to repeat.


4. Same Challenge, Different Dog: Why One Training Method Doesn't Fit All


Imagine visitors arriving at your home. One dog may rush to the door, tail moving, ready to investigate every new arrival. Another may remain at a comfortable distance, watching the visitors before deciding whether to approach. Neither response is automatically wrong.


The social butterfly may need help learning that greeting people does not mean everyone is available for enthusiastic personal introductions. The more reserved dog may need a calm environment where it can observe without being pressured to interact.


The training goal can be the same: a dog who remains comfortable and manageable when visitors arrive. But the path to that goal may look very different.


This is something responsible owners and breeders need to recognize. We should not expect a reserved dog to become indiscriminately social, nor should we allow an outgoing dog to overwhelm everyone around it. Good training respects the dog's temperament while teaching appropriate behaviour.


It is not about changing the dog's personality. It is about helping the dog navigate the human world successfully.


5. Learn to Speak Dog: Your Dog Has Been Talking All Along


Dogs communicate constantly. The challenge is that much of their communication is quiet, subtle and easy for people to miss. They use posture, movement, facial expression, ears, tails, vocalizations and scent. These signals need to be interpreted together and in context.


A wagging tail, for example, does not automatically mean a dog is friendly. A wag tells us that the dog is emotionally activated, but the rest of its body helps us understand what might be happening.


A dog can also yawn, lick its lips, turn its head or sniff the ground for many reasons. These behaviours may occur during moments of social tension, but context matters. A yawn after waking up is not necessarily a sign of stress.


A practical body-language guide


Relaxed and comfortable

· Loose, fluid body movement.

· Soft facial expression.

· Natural posture without obvious tension.

· Ability to move away or disengage comfortably.


Excited and highly aroused

· Increased movement and energy.

· Faster or more exaggerated tail movement.

· Jumping, bouncing or vocalizing.

· Difficulty settling or responding to familiar cues.


Excitement is not always happiness. A highly aroused dog may need help calming down before it can make good decisions.


Uncertain or uncomfortable

· Turning the head or body away.

· Lip licking or repeated yawning in a tense situation.

· Lowered posture or weight shifted backwards.

· Trying to create distance or avoid interaction.


Potentially escalating discomfort

· A stiff body and reduced movement.

· Fixed or intense staring.

· Tension around the mouth.

· Growling, snapping or other defensive behaviour.


These are not rigid diagnostic checklists. A dog's body shape, age, health, breed characteristics and the surrounding situation all influence how its signals appear.


One signal deserves particular respect: the growl


A growl is communication. It may mean that a dog is uncomfortable, worried, guarding something or asking for more distance. Punishing the growl does not necessarily remove the discomfort that caused it. It may simply teach the dog not to give that warning next time.

Instead, stop the interaction, create space and investigate what made the dog uncomfortable. This is especially important when children and dogs share a home. Children should not chase, corner, hug or disturb a dog that is eating or resting. Supervision and teaching children to respect canine boundaries are essential.

 

A calm, respectful interaction gives a dog room to choose whether to engage.
A calm, respectful interaction gives a dog room to choose whether to engage.

And then there is scent. Dogs gather information through smell in ways that are difficult for us to appreciate. What looks like an unnecessarily long investigation of a patch of grass may be the canine equivalent of catching up on neighbourhood news. Let them sniff. Sometimes the walk is not about the distance covered.


6. What Temperament Means to a Responsible Breeder


Understanding temperament is not just useful after a puppy goes home. It should begin long before that. For a breeder, temperament is one of the most important considerations in a breeding program. Physical structure, health and breed type matter, but a beautiful dog with an unsuitable or unstable temperament does not represent the whole picture of responsible breeding.


At Last Samurai Kennel, we believe that preserving the character of a breed means understanding what makes that breed distinctive while prioritizing stable, confident and socially sound dogs.


That requires looking beyond a single puppy's behaviour on a particular day. We consider the temperaments of the parents, how they behave as mature dogs, their responses to unfamiliar situations and their ability to live comfortably in everyday environments.


A puppy's early development matters too. Maternal behaviour, litter experiences, handling, socialization and the environment in which a puppy grows all contribute to development.

And when it comes to matching puppies with families, appearance or coat colour should never be the only consideration. A highly active, socially outgoing puppy may suit one household, while a more thoughtful or independent puppy may be a better fit for another.


This is also why we are careful about making promises based on a puppy assessment. A short observation or temperament test can offer useful information, but it cannot guarantee exactly who that puppy will become as an adult.


Temperament develops over time. Responsible breeding means making informed decisions, being honest about what we observe and helping families choose a dog whose needs and tendencies fit their lifestyle.


We are not trying to produce identical dogs. We are trying to preserve sound, recognizable breed characteristics while respecting the individuality of every puppy.


7. The Dog You Have, Not the Dog You Imagined


Perhaps the most useful change we can make as dog owners is to stop comparing our dogs with an imaginary standard of what a dog should be. Not every dog wants to greet strangers. Not every dog finds repetitive exercises exciting. Not every dog learns in the same way, responds to the same rewards or enjoys the same social experiences.


And that is perfectly normal. A Shiba's independence should not be mistaken for a lack of affection. A Samoyed's enthusiasm should not be mistaken for an inability to settle. A quiet dog is not automatically confident, and an outgoing dog is not automatically well-adjusted.

We need to look at the individual in front of us. That means observing, learning, adjusting expectations and providing training that makes sense for the dog we actually live with. It also means recognizing when a behaviour needs professional help rather than explaining everything away as a breed trait.


Breed knowledge is valuable. Individual assessment is essential.

 

Understanding the individual dog is where thoughtful ownership begins.
Understanding the individual dog is where thoughtful ownership begins.

Final Thoughts: Understanding Comes Before Expectations


Dogs spend their lives learning our language. They learn our routines, our gestures, our expectations and sometimes even our moods. It is only fair that we make an effort to learn theirs.


When we understand temperament, motivation and communication, training becomes more than a series of commands. It becomes a conversation built on trust, observation and mutual understanding.


The next time your dog ignores a cue, pauses before approaching someone or chooses to investigate something instead of following your plan, take a moment before calling it stubborn. Ask yourself what the dog might be experiencing, what it has learned and what it needs from you.


Sometimes the problem isn't that your dog isn't listening. Sometimes, we simply haven't learned how to listen to the dog.


References and Further Reading


· Coren, S. (1994). The Intelligence of Dogs.

· Jones, A. C., & Gosling, S. D. (2005). Temperament and personality in dogs (Canis familiaris): A review and evaluation of past research. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 95, 1–53.

· Siniscalchi, M., et al. (2013). Seeing left-or right-asymmetric tail wagging produces different emotional responses in dogs. Current Biology, 23, 2279–2282.

· McGuire, J. K., et al. (2020). Abilities of canine shelter behavioral evaluations and owner surrender profiles to predict resource guarding in adoptive homes. Animals, 10(9), 1702.


Comments


bottom of page