THE UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTH ABOUT SHIBA INU TEMPERAMENT
Is the Shiba Inu really a difficult breed, or have we simply forgotten what kind of dog we brought home?
Let's talk about Shiba Inus. And perhaps a few things that might make some people uncomfortable.
Having Shibas as part of my life and breeding program has taught me that there are very few breeds as misunderstood as this one. I have seen the sweet, affectionate, playful side of them, but I have also seen that wonderfully independent personality that makes you question whether you actually own a dog or simply share your house with a very opinionated roommate.
Ask a room full of Shiba Inu owners what life with their dogs is like, and you will probably get some interesting answers.
Some will tell you their Shiba is the easiest dog they have ever owned. Others will describe a furry little dictator who negotiates every command, has selective hearing, and considers recall a personal insult.
Honestly, I can understand both sides.
The Shiba Inu is an intelligent, independent, confident, and often strong-willed breed. It was not developed to spend its days waiting for someone to tell it what to do. Historically, these dogs needed initiative, awareness, agility, and the ability to work independently.
Those characteristics did not magically disappear when the breed moved into our living rooms.
Yet I increasingly see expectations placed on Shibas that seem better suited to an entirely different type of dog. We want perfect recall, effortless socialization, immediate compliance, friendly interactions with every dog they meet, and the ability to fit seamlessly into every household.
And when they don't? We call them stubborn, difficult, antisocial, or poorly behaved.
I think it's time we reconsider some of those expectations.
1. The Shiba Inu is independent. That doesn't automatically mean something went wrong.

One of the most common misconceptions I encounter about Shiba Inus is that independence equals poor socialization or a questionable temperament.
I disagree.
A Shiba doesn't necessarily need constant attention. Some are affectionate but not particularly cuddly. Some enjoy being around their families without needing to be physically attached to them every waking minute. Others are perfectly content entertaining themselves.
And yes, some will happily choose the other end of the sofa when you were hoping for a cuddle.
I don't consider that a character flaw.
There is an important distinction between a dog that is comfortable being independent and a dog that is fearful, uncomfortable, or unable to cope with its environment.
In my opinion, a well-adjusted Shiba should be able to navigate everyday situations with confidence. It should not need to love every person or every dog it encounters to be considered socially sound.
The Japanese concept of ryosei emphasizes good nature, loyalty, and a sound disposition. It doesn't mean indiscriminate friendliness.
When I evaluate temperament, I want to see confidence, stability, and the ability to interact appropriately with the environment. I don't need every dog to behave like a social butterfly.
I also don't believe that a Shiba who politely declines a stranger's invitation to become best friends has somehow failed its socialization program.
Congratulations. You own a Shiba Inu.
2. Should every Shiba Inu have perfect recall?

Now, this is a subject I could probably discuss over several cups of coffee.
Recall.
There seems to be an expectation that a well-trained dog should come running every time its owner calls. And while reliable recall is an important training goal, I think we sometimes forget that not every breed was developed with the same working relationship with humans.
The Shiba Inu has a history as an independent hunting dog. Its natural instincts include alertness, environmental awareness, prey interest, and the ability to make decisions without constant human direction.
Put a Shiba in an environment with squirrels, rabbits, birds, or other exciting distractions, and suddenly your carefully rehearsed recall command may become the least interesting thing in the world.
If you've ever watched a Shiba spot something interesting in the distance, you probably know exactly what I mean.
This doesn't mean Shibas cannot learn recall. They absolutely can.
I believe in training, consistency, positive reinforcement, and giving dogs the tools to succeed. But I also believe in understanding the dog in front of us rather than measuring every breed against the same expectations.
There is a difference between teaching a behaviour and expecting that behaviour to be reliable under every possible circumstance.
Genetics matter. Individual temperament matters. Environment matters.
I would much rather see an owner use a long line, secure fencing, and sensible management than take unnecessary risks just to prove their Shiba can walk off-leash.
A Shiba Inu that cannot be trusted off-leash is not automatically a badly trained Shiba Inu.
I don't consider off-leash freedom the ultimate measurement of intelligence, obedience, or the quality of a dog.
Responsible ownership sometimes means accepting that a particular dog has limitations, regardless of how much training we invest.
3. Independence is not an excuse for poor temperament.

Now, before anyone misunderstands my position, let me make something very clear.
I will defend the natural characteristics of the Shiba Inu all day long, but I will never use breed characteristics as an excuse for poor temperament.
There is a difference between independence and instability.
A confident Shiba may choose not to interact with another dog. It may prefer distance from unfamiliar people. It may be selective about its canine companions.
That is very different from a dog that cannot tolerate normal everyday situations.
I believe we have a responsibility to preserve the qualities that make the Shiba Inu unique while still producing dogs that can live harmoniously in modern households.
That means I take temperament seriously.
When I plan a breeding, I don't look at titles and conformation alone. Health, temperament, structure, pedigree, and the qualities each individual dog can contribute to future generations all matter.
A beautiful dog is not automatically a good breeding prospect.
I also put considerable importance on how puppies are raised and introduced to the world. Early experiences matter. Puppies need positive, age-appropriate exposure to different environments, sounds, surfaces, people, handling, and other dogs.
But socialization is not about forcing a puppy to meet everyone.
It's about helping that puppy develop confidence and learn how to navigate everyday life without becoming overwhelmed.
I don't need my Shibas to attend every dog park party. I do want them to be able to exist peacefully in public.
There is a rather important difference.
4. Should Shiba Inus really be recommended as family dogs?

This is another conversation I think we need to have more honestly.
Yes, Shiba Inus can make wonderful family companions. I have seen how affectionate, entertaining, and devoted these dogs can be with their people.
But would I recommend a Shiba Inu to absolutely every family?
No.
And I don't think any responsible breeder should.
The Shiba Inu is not necessarily the best choice for a household expecting a dog that tolerates everything, enjoys constant physical affection, and happily participates in every family activity.
Some Shibas have limited tolerance for rough handling, unpredictable interactions, and excessive physical attention. They may dislike being hugged, restrained, disturbed while resting, or handled by unfamiliar children.
And that's perfectly fine, provided we understand and respect those boundaries.
When I speak with prospective puppy families, I want them to understand that bringing home a Shiba Inu means accepting the whole package, not just the adorable puppy face.
Children need to learn how to respect dogs. Dogs need appropriate boundaries and safe spaces. Parents need to supervise interactions rather than assuming that a puppy will automatically grow into a tolerant family dog.
I believe puppy placement should be about compatibility, not simply finding someone who wants to buy a puppy.
Sometimes, the right decision is to tell a family that another breed might be a better fit.
I would rather have that conversation before a puppy goes home than receive a call six months later because the family expected a completely different dog.
That isn't bad customer service. It's responsible breeding.

5. What I look for as a breeder: More than a pretty face and a championship title.


I think this is where I have the strongest opinions.
The Shiba Inu is a beautiful breed, and I certainly appreciate a well-constructed dog with correct breed type. After all, conformation and preservation are important parts of my breeding program.
But I don't believe a beautiful Shiba with an impressive pedigree is automatically a good breeding dog.
Temperament deserves just as much consideration.
I want to see confident, stable dogs that can navigate their environment without unnecessary fear or insecurity. I want to understand the personalities behind the pedigrees, not just the names and titles printed on them.
When making breeding decisions, I consider:
· The temperament and behaviour of both parents.
· Health testing and the health history of the family lines.
· Correct structure and adherence to the breed standard.
· Genetic diversity and the long-term health of the breed.
· The qualities each individual dog can contribute to future generations.
· The development and temperament of previous offspring, where that information is available.
I also believe breeders should be willing to look honestly at the results of their decisions.
Producing beautiful puppies is wonderful. Producing healthy, stable dogs that grow into good representatives of their breed is what I consider a much greater achievement.
I don't want to breed Shibas simply because people love the way they look.
I want to contribute to preserving the dog that made me fall in love with this breed in the first place.
6. So, is the Shiba Inu difficult?

My answer?
Sometimes, absolutely.
But difficult compared to what?
A Shiba Inu may challenge an owner's patience in ways that a more biddable breed might not. It may require a different training approach, more thoughtful management, and a better understanding of canine behaviour.
It may not be particularly interested in pleasing you simply because you asked nicely.
And sometimes, after spending twenty minutes explaining why coming inside is a wonderful idea, your Shiba will look directly into your eyes and decide that the garden is still more interesting.
I suspect many Shiba owners have experienced this particular negotiation.
But difficult does not mean defective.
Independent does not mean antisocial.
Selective does not mean poorly socialized.
And a dog that doesn't blindly obey every command is not necessarily a poorly trained dog.
The Shiba Inu was never meant to be a miniature obedience robot with a curled tail.
It is a primitive Japanese breed with a distinct history, character, and set of instincts.
Understanding those characteristics is part of responsible ownership.
I don't believe our goal should be to make every Shiba behave like every other breed. Our goal should be to preserve its desirable characteristics while ensuring that our dogs are healthy, stable, confident, and capable of living harmoniously with people.
A final thought: Should we change the breed, or change our expectations?

As someone who has chosen to dedicate part of my life to this breed, I feel a responsibility to look beyond what is fashionable or commercially desirable.
I want my Shibas to be beautiful, yes. I want them to represent the breed standard, have good health, and possess sound temperaments.
But I also want them to remain Shibas.
I don't want to breed away every independent characteristic simply because some buyers would prefer a dog that behaves differently. I don't want to confuse a desirable temperament with a completely different personality.
Preserving a breed means understanding what makes it unique, improving what genuinely needs improvement, and resisting the temptation to remove every characteristic that makes ownership a little more challenging.
Because if we eventually breed away everything that makes the Shiba Inu a Shiba Inu, what exactly are we preserving?
And perhaps that's a question worth asking ourselves more often.

Comments